Production and Consumption based accounting

Understanding the Difference Between Production-Based and Consumption-Based Accounting for Greenhouse Gas Emissions

When measuring and reporting greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, two primary accounting approaches are often used: production-based accounting and consumption-based accounting. Both methods provide valuable insights, but they focus on different aspects of emissions and can lead to different conclusions about a country's or region's contribution to global emissions. Let’s explore the key differences between these two approaches and understand how they relate to each other.

1. Production-Based Accounting

Production-based accounting (also known as territorial or supply-side accounting) measures the total GHG emissions produced within a specific geographic area, such as a country or city. This approach accounts for all emissions generated from the production of goods and services within the boundaries of that region, regardless of where these goods and services are ultimately consumed.

Key Characteristics:

• Focus on Location of Emission: It counts emissions based on where they physically occur.
• Includes All Sectors: Covers all emissions from industrial processes, energy production, agriculture, waste management, and other sectors within the region.
• Commonly Used for National Reporting: This method aligns with the reporting requirements of international agreements such as the Kyoto Protocol and the Paris Agreement.

2. Consumption-Based Accounting

Consumption-based accounting (also known as demand-side or footprint accounting) measures the total GHG emissions associated with the consumption of goods and services by the residents of a specific geographic area, regardless of where those goods and services were produced. This approach considers the entire supply chain, including emissions from imported goods and services, and subtracts emissions from exported goods and services.

Key Characteristics:

• Focus on Final Consumption: It attributes emissions to the end-user or consumer of goods and services, not where the emissions occur.
• Global Supply Chain Consideration: Takes into account the full lifecycle emissions of products, including production, transportation, and disposal, across global supply chains.
• Highlights Carbon Footprint: This method helps understand the carbon footprint of residents, providing insights into the indirect emissions associated with consumption patterns.

3. Equation Relating Production-Based and Consumption-Based Accounting

To relate the two approaches, we use an equation that accounts for the emissions from imports and exports:

Consumption-Based Emissions  = Production-Based Emissions + Emissions from Imports - Emissions from Exports 

Where:

•  Production-Based Emissions: Emissions produced within a country or region.
•  Emissions from Imports: Emissions embedded in goods and services imported into the country or region.
• Emissions from Exports: Emissions embedded in goods and services exported from the country or region.

This equation highlights how emissions are transferred across borders due to international trade. 

Below is a diagram that visually represents the difference between production-based and consumption-based accounting:

Diagram Explanation:

• Production-Based Emissions are represented within the borders of Country n and Country m, showing emissions generated from local production activities.
• Consumption-Based Emissions are illustrated by arrows moving towards the countries that consume the goods, regardless of where they were produced.
• Imports and Exports: Arrows also depict the flow of goods and services across countries. Country n's imports (coming in) add to its consumption-based emissions, while its exports (going out) are subtracted.

 5. Why Both Accounting Methods Matter

1. Policy Implications: Production-based accounting aligns with international climate agreements and helps track national commitments to reducing emissions. In contrast, consumption-based accounting provides insights into the global responsibility of countries, especially those with high import rates of carbon-intensive goods.
2. Responsibility and Equity: Consumption-based accounting highlights the global nature of climate change, showing how developed countries often "outsource" their emissions by importing goods from developing countries.
3. Holistic View: Combining both methods offers a more comprehensive understanding of a country's overall impact on global emissions and can guide more effective and equitable climate policies.

By understanding both production and consumption-based accounting, policymakers and businesses can better address emissions across the entire value chain and work towards comprehensive climate solutions. 

Both production-based and consumption-based accounting provide essential perspectives on greenhouse gas emissions. While production-based accounting focuses on emissions within a region, consumption-based accounting allocates emissions to consumers based on their consumption patterns. Together, these methods offer a complete picture of a region's contribution to global emissions, guiding better-informed climate policies and actions.

For more free resources, please click on the Cheatsheet

---

    Why support?